RTI reveals the MHA GOI has no information related to any of the History Sheeters of INDIA ; If national security is at risk due to this ?

RTI reveals the MHA GOI has no information related to any of the
History Sheeters of INDIA ; If national security is at risk due to
this ?
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Respected All ,

I sent a RTI petition on 20-09-2010 to the CPIO of Ministry of Home
Affairs ( MHA ) of the Government of India ( GOI ) demanding info on 5
points related to the History Sheeters of all states of India and the
Central Government's policies to deal with matters related to the
History Sheeters . The RTI petition is attached as attachment 1 to
this mail . The same is available at given link also -

http://aishwaryaj.hpage.com/rti_petition_mha_goi_historysheeters_20sept10_93019363.html

Scanned copy of RTI reply sent Vide O.M. no. A-43020/01/2010-RTI
dated 29th September 2010 , issued by Sri S.K. Bhatnagar , Director &
CPIO , MHA , GOI ( ph. No. 011 – 23092035 ) is also attached as
attachment 2 to this mail , The same is available at given link also -

http://file1.hpage.com/000223/57/bilder/histry_sheeter_mha_goi_20_sept_10.jpg

The Case raises two issues to be considered –

1- Pure RTI related issue

a- The CPIO of MHA has skipped point wise reply which violates section
7 (9) of RTI act . This issue shall be raised with the FAA while
sending the first appeal u/s 19(1). Isn't it that the CPIOs are
ridiculing the act and going scot free ?

b- The CPIO has mentioned one Office Memorandum No. 10/2/2008-IR
dated 12-06-2008 of DOPT and has grossly violated section 6(3) of the
RTI act 2005 . This OM of DOPT empowers the CPIO to murder the letters
of section 6(3) , and the spirit of sections 5(3) , 5(4) , 5(5) ,
6(1) & 28 of RTI act in broad daylight with all of us watching it
happen as a mute spectator and bearing with it as a helpless lot.
Tough I shall raise my objections but they are going to be of no help
because of this OM of DOPT . My hopes lies with the central
info-commission / the High Court . Isn't this OM of DOPT making the
RTI act useless for a common rural man who really doesn't know which
is his PIO and making second application is too difficult to him ?

2- The issue of Nation's Security & humanitarian needs

a- The Central Home ministry has no information about the History
sheeter criminals of the nation . History sheeters are generally the
hardcore criminals and can easily be used as soft targets for all
anti-national activities by the traitors of the nation . Keeping no
tab on them by the central government expose the nation to potential
security risk. Shouldn't this record be readily available with
central home ministry ?

b- On a humanitarian front , shouldn't there be an effort to make
special budgetary provisions to bring these special criminals into the
mainstream normal life and do something special to rehabilitate them ?

please think and if convinced , please do write to GOI in this matter
with your suggestions/ recommendation to GOI .

Regards

Urvashi Sharma
Social Worker & RTI Activist
F - 2376 , Rajajipuram , Lucknow
Uttar Pradesh , India PIN CODE - 226017
contact 9369613513 , 9305463313 , 9455553838
--
Urvashi Sharma

RTI Helpmail( Web Based )
aishwaryaj2010@gmail.com

Mobile Rti Helpline
8081898081 ( 8 A.M. to 10 P.M. )