To :
Sri Man Mohan Singh
The Prime Minister of India
Government of India , P.M.O. , South Block
New Delhi , India , Pin Code – 110001
"Hon'ble Prime Miister of India Dr. Man Mohan Singh" pmosb@pmo.nic.in ,
From :
Members of " YAISHWARYAJ " and " SURYA " , the Lucknow and Bareilly
, Uttar Pradesh , India based AOP , involved in Social Activism
Date :
03rd of November , 2010
Re. : Alarming trend indicated by the Corruption Perception Index
figures Released by Transparency International for last 10 years
involving both Pre and post Right to Information Act periods ,
Introspection and Action needed at the Government of India Level to
combat the corruption by ensuring Compliance of Right to Information
Act 2005 in " letter & spirit "
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
On behalf of the Members of " YAISHWARYAJ " & " SURYA ", the
undersigned have drafted this memorandum to communicate our collective
concerns for the alarming situation of rising Corruption in the
Country , as indicated by the data released by Transparency
International for last 10 years involving both Pre and post Right to
Information Act periods.
We are alarmed and distressed to learn from the recent newspaper
reports and website of the of Transparency International that for
the year 2010 , India moved up the ladder of corruption despite there
being an act called the Right to Information Act 2005 .
We, the Social activists from Uttar Pradesh , discussed RTI Act 2005
vis-à-vis Corruption Perception index Data released by Transparency
International and decided to send this memorandum to you with the
demand to constitute a committee to study this scenario in the light
of implementation of Right to Information Act 2005 in " letter &
spirit " since 2005 to date .
The Preamble of the RTI Act 2005 states "And whereas democracy
requires an informed citizenry and transparency of information which
are vital to its functioning and also to contain corruption and to
hold Governments and their instrumentalities accountable to the
governed; "
Here emphasis has been laid on the words " to contain corruption "
means prime motive of enacting this act was to contain corruption and
the spirit of the act was to diminish it gradually.
As per Transparency International's annual survey ,India slipped from
84th position to 87th. It means India has become more corrupt than
year before despite there being an important tool called " RTI act
2005 " to contain corruption . On a Scale which ranges from zero
(perceived to be highly corrupt) to 10 (thought to have little
corruption) , India scored 3.3 in the corruption perception index,
which ranks countries on a scale from 10 (highly clean) to 0 (highly
corrupt).
Corruption's ultimate consequences has to be borne by the poor ,
vulnerable and deprived section of the society . This section
constitutes the largest chunk of India's Population.
So we collected Corruption Perception Index Data from the Transparency
International's Website from year 2001 to 2010. The Time period
selected involved both Pre and post Right to Information Act periods
. The data tables are given below –
Table – 1
YEAR COUNTRY
RANK COUNTRY C.P.I.
SCORE CONFIDANCE
RANGE/LOW-HIGH RANGE SURVEYS
USED
2001 71 INDIA 2.7 2.1 – 3.8 12
2002 71 INDIA 2.7 2.4 – 3.6 12
2003 83 INDIA 2.8 2.1 – 3.6 14
2004 90 INDIA 2.8 2.6 – 3.0 15
2005 88 INDIA 2.9 2.7 – 3.1 14
2006 70 INDIA 3.3 3.1 – 3.6 10
2007 72 INDIA 3.5 3.3 – 3.7 10
2008 85 INDIA 3.4 2.7 – 3.9 10
2009 84 INDIA 3.4 3.2 – 3.6 10
2010 87 INDIA 3.3 3.0 – 3.5 10
Table – 2
YEAR C.P.I. SCORE
2001 2.7
2002 2.7
2003 2.8
2004 2.8
2005 2.9
2006 3.3
2007 3.5
2008 3.4
2009 3.4
2010 3.3
The C.P.I. data for these 10 years show that in these ten years India was -
• the least honest in year 2001 with C.P.I. Score of 2.7,
• showed no improvement in year 2002 with unchanged C.P.I. Score of 2.7 ,
• showed improvement of 3.70% in year 2003 with C.P.I. Score of 2.8 ,
• showed no improvement in 2004 with unchanged C.P.I. Score of 2.8 ,
• showed improvement of 3.57% in year 2005 with C.P.I. Score of 2.9,
• showed improvement of 13.79% in year 2006 with C.P.I. Score of 3.3,
• showed improvement of 6.06% in year 2007 with C.P.I. Score of 3.5,
• showed decline of 2.86% in year 2008 with C.P.I. Score of 3.4,
• showed no change in 2009 with unchanged C.P.I. Score of 3.4,
• showed decline of 2.94% in year 2010 with C.P.I. Score of 3.3,
The analysis shows that India raised on honesty scale from 2001 to
2007 and is continuously declining from 2008 to date despite there
being a strong tool to fight corruption i.e. " Right to Information
Act 2005 " .
The remarkable point of study is that with the advent of RTI act 2005
in the year 2005 , corruption diminished by 13.79% in year 2006 and
further by 6.06% in year 2007. From 2008 onwards corruption is showing
continuous increasing trend thereby raising a question as to for
what purpose the RTI act was enacted and if it is serving that purpose
or not ?
We discussed the matter and we are of the view that there is strong
need for the Government of India to introspect as to for what
purpose the RTI act was enacted and if it is serving that purpose? If
no , then what are the factors responsible for this contradictory
situation of rising corruption in India despite there being a strong
tool called " Right to Information Act 2005 " ?
We are sending this memorandum to you to look into the matter with
desired seriousness , Constitute a Committee having considerable
representation of civil societies to analyze the factors responsible
for this undesirable situation of rising corruption thereby implying
failure of " RTI Act 2005 " in the Country and take other appropriate
measures as may deem fit by your office in this regard to safeguard
the interests of all the people of the nation .
Copy being sent for necessary action by E-mail to - Smt. Pratibha
Devisingh Patil ,The President of India, President House , New Delhi ,
Pin Code – 110001 , India. "Her Excellency President of India Smt.
Pratibha Devisingh Patil" presidentofindia@rb.nic.in ,
Yours truly ,
The Signatories –
1- Urvashi Sharma
2- Usha
3- Prabhuta
4- Babita Singh
5- Anjali
6- Vishal Pandey
7- Premisagar
8- Vadam Singh
9- Ramautar
10-Ram Prakash
11-Vishnu Datt
e-mail rtimahilamanchup@yahoo.co.in
--
Urvashi Sharma
RTI Helpmail( Web Based )
aishwaryaj2010@gmail.com
Mobile Rti Helpline
8081898081 ( 8 A.M. to 10 P.M. )
No comments:
Post a Comment